When people start looking into new gutters, one of the first questions that comes up is size. Most homes have 5-inch gutters, but more and more homeowners are hearing about 6-inch options. So which is better? The short answer is: it depends on your roof, your rainfall, and the way your home is built. The longer answer takes a little digging.

​

Why Gutter Size Matters

Gutters are simple. They catch water from your roof and send it away from your foundation. But the size determines how much water they can actually handle at once. A 5-inch gutter is the standard and has been used on the majority of homes for decades. A 6-inch gutter has a wider opening and holds more water—around 40% more. That difference becomes important if you live in an area with heavy rainfall or if your roof pushes a lot of water toward one spot.

 

If the gutters are too small for the volume of water coming off the roof, you’ll see them overflow. Water spilling over the side doesn’t just look bad. It can ruin landscaping, wash out soil, stain siding, and—most importantly—damage your foundation. Over time, that overflow can also rot fascia boards and leak into soffits. So it’s not just about “looks” or upgrading for fun. It’s a functional decision.

 

The Case for 5-Inch Gutters

For many homes, 5-inch gutters are perfectly fine. They’re cheaper than 6-inch, easier to install, and usually fit better with standard fascia board setups without requiring modifications. If you live in a moderate rainfall area, have a relatively simple roofline, and don’t have steep pitches directing a lot of water to one spot, 5-inch gutters will likely do the job.

 

Contractors like them because they’re standard. Accessories like downspouts, guards, and hangers are widely available. Maintenance is usually easier too, since the gutters are smaller and a little less awkward to clean or repair.

 

So, if your house is average-sized, your roof isn’t unusually large or steep, and you’re not dealing with storms that dump several inches of rain in a short time, 5-inch gutters remain a reliable choice.

​

The Case for 6-Inch Gutters

Now, when do 6-inch gutters make sense? The main factors are rainfall intensity, roof size, and roof design.

​

1. Rainfall: Areas with frequent heavy downpours, like the Southeast U.S. or coastal regions, often benefit from larger gutters. A 6-inch gutter with oversized downspouts can move a lot more water, reducing overflow during storms.

2. Roof size: Bigger roofs shed more water. It’s not just the square footage but also the pitch. A steep roof moves water faster, which means the gutters need to catch and drain it quickly.

3. Roof design: Homes with complicated layouts—multiple valleys, intersecting rooflines, or long stretches of roof leading into a single gutter section—tend to overwhelm 5-inch systems. A 6-inch gutter is better at handling those concentrated flows.

 

Another advantage: 6-inch gutters can handle larger downspouts, usually 3x4 inches instead of the standard 2x3. That’s important because downspouts are often the bottleneck. If they can’t drain quickly enough, even the biggest gutter will back up.

The trade-off? They cost more. Material prices, installation, and accessories are all a step up. They also take up a little more visual space on the edge of the roof, which some people don’t like aesthetically.

​

What Happens if Gutters Are Undersized

If gutters are too small, the problems are almost guaranteed over time. Water spilling over the top can:

​

• Pool near the foundation, leading to cracks or basement leaks.

• Rot wooden trim and fascia boards.

• Stain siding and cause mold or mildew growth.

• Wash out landscaping or damage walkways.

​

These aren’t just cosmetic issues. Foundation repair, for example, is significantly more expensive than paying for the right gutter size upfront. Oversized gutters may feel unnecessary if your 5-inch system “mostly works,” but you need to think about long-term damage.

 

How to Decide Between 5 and 6-Inch Gutters

There isn’t one right answer for everyone. A contractor usually calculates roof drainage needs using square footage and slope. They’ll also consider local rainfall data. The basic idea is that every 1 inch of rain on 1,000 square feet of roof produces about 600 gallons of water. Multiply that across a big roof during a storm, and the volume adds up fast.

​

Here’s how to narrow it down:

• Choose 5-inch if your home is average-sized (around 2,000 sq ft), your roof design is simple, and you don’t experience frequent heavy storms.

• Choose 6-inch if you have a large or steep roof, complicated valleys, or live in a region with intense rain events.

 

Sometimes homeowners even mix sizes—using 5-inch gutters on less demanding sections and 6-inch where heavy flows collect. That’s worth asking about if you’re trying to balance performance and budget.

​

Mistakes to Avoid

1. Ignoring downspout size. Gutters can only move water as fast as the downspouts allow. Upgrading gutters without larger downspouts is a wasted effort.

2. Thinking only about cost. Cheaper upfront doesn’t mean cheaper long term. Oversized gutters may save you thousands in repairs later.

3. Skipping professional advice. Guessing isn’t a good idea. Roof drainage math is straightforward for contractors, but most homeowners don’t calculate properly.

4. Focusing only on width. Material, installation quality, and slope of the gutter run matter too. A poorly installed 6-inch gutter can still fail.

​

Maintenance Considerations

Both 5-inch and 6-inch gutters need cleaning and maintenance. But wider gutters have a small advantage—they’re less likely to clog because debris has more room before creating a blockage. Pairing them with oversized downspouts also helps. If you plan to use gutter guards, check compatibility. Some guards are made for 5-inch only, while others fit both.

​

Cost Differences

On average, 6-inch gutters cost about 15–25% more than 5-inch. The price difference depends on the material (aluminum, steel, copper) and whether you’re also upgrading downspouts and hangers. For many homeowners, that added cost is worth it if it prevents water damage. But if your home doesn’t actually need them, it may be money wasted.

​

Final Thoughts

So, is it better to have 5 or 6-inch gutters? Better isn’t universal. It’s about matching gutter capacity to your roof and your climate. Five-inch gutters remain standard and perfectly fine for many homes. Six-inch gutters handle more water, fit larger roofs, and reduce overflow risks in heavy rain areas. The real mistake is choosing without looking at the numbers. A good contractor can run the calculations, check your roof layout, and give you a clear recommendation.

 

If you’re replacing gutters and already dealing with overflow or water pooling, that’s usually a sign you should upgrade to 6-inch. If your current 5-inch gutters work fine and you’re not seeing issues, sticking with them makes sense. The right choice comes down to function, not trend.