What is the best type of shingle for roofing?

When people ask what the best shingle is for roofing, they usually expect a one-word answer. Asphalt. Slate. Metal. Something quick. The problem is that roofing shingles aren’t “one-size-fits-all.” What works best for a house in Florida isn’t always right for a house in Minnesota. The “best” type of shingle depends on budget, climate, style preferences, and how long you want the roof to last. Instead of chasing one single winner, it makes more sense to look at the main options and understand where each shines and where it doesn’t.

Asphalt Shingles: The Most Common

Asphalt shingles are by far the most popular roofing material in the U.S. Roughly 70% of American homes use them. Why? Price and availability. You can get a full asphalt shingle roof for significantly less than slate or metal. Installation is also faster because almost every roofer knows how to work with them.

There are two main types: three-tab and architectural (sometimes called dimensional) shingles. Three-tab is the cheaper, thinner version. Architectural shingles are thicker, layered, and have a more dimensional look that mimics wood or stone.

Cost: $5–$9 per square foot installed (varies by region).
Lifespan: 15–30 years, depending on quality.
Strengths: Affordable, widely available, decent warranties.
Weaknesses: Shorter lifespan than premium materials, vulnerable to high winds and extreme temperature swings.

If you’re on a budget and need a reliable roof without luxury expectations, asphalt is usually the best choice. But if you live somewhere with constant storms, hail, or extreme heat, asphalt may wear out faster than you want.

Architectural Asphalt vs. Standard Three-Tab

People often ask whether it’s worth upgrading to architectural shingles. In most cases, yes. They’re about 20–40% more expensive than three-tab, but they’re thicker, more durable, and have better warranties. Many manufacturers offer 30-year or even “lifetime” warranties on architectural shingles, although “lifetime” usually means about 50 years under specific conditions. They also stand up better against wind (rated up to 120 mph in some cases, compared to 60 mph for cheaper shingles).

If you plan to stay in your house longer than 10 years, architectural shingles usually justify the extra cost.

Metal Shingles: Strong but Pricey

Metal roofing has been around for centuries, but metal shingles and panels have gained popularity in recent decades. They can be made from steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper.

Cost: $9–$14 per square foot installed.
Lifespan: 40–70 years.
Strengths: Fire-resistant, energy-efficient, excellent wind resistance, sheds snow easily, recyclable.
Weaknesses: Higher upfront cost, potential for noise without proper insulation, not always HOA-friendly in neighborhoods with strict design rules.

Metal shingles or panels are best for homeowners who want a long-term solution and don’t mind the higher upfront investment. In snowy regions, metal sheds snow before ice dams can form, which helps prevent leaks. In hot climates, reflective coatings can reduce cooling costs.

The downside is cost. A metal roof might be double or triple the cost of asphalt. But spread over 50+ years, it can actually be cheaper long-term.

Wood Shingles and Shakes: Traditional but High-Maintenance

Wood shingles (machine-cut) and wood shakes (hand-split, thicker, rougher) have a distinct look. Many older homes and historic districts still use them because they’re authentic to the architecture.

Cost: $6–$10 per square foot installed.
Lifespan: 20–40 years.
Strengths: Natural, attractive appearance, decent insulation value.
Weaknesses: Vulnerable to fire, insects, mold, and rot unless treated. Regular maintenance required.

In dry climates, wood shingles can last decades. In wet or humid areas, they require frequent maintenance and may not be the best choice. Some areas with wildfire risks ban wood roofs altogether.

Slate Shingles: The Longest-Lasting

Slate shingles are cut from natural stone. They are heavy, expensive, and require a skilled installer. But if you want a roof that could last a century, slate is unmatched.

Cost: $15–$30 per square foot installed.
Lifespan: 75–150 years.
Strengths: Incredible durability, fireproof, natural look.
Weaknesses: Extremely heavy (may require structural reinforcement), expensive, limited availability of experienced installers.

Slate makes sense if you own a historic property, plan to stay for life, or want to invest in a roof you’ll never need to replace. For most homeowners, though, the cost and weight make it impractical.

Synthetic Shingles: A Modern Alternative

Synthetic shingles (also called composite shingles) are designed to mimic slate, wood, or even tile. They’re usually made from a mix of polymers, rubber, and recycled materials.

Cost: $7–$12 per square foot installed.
Lifespan: 40–50 years (depending on brand).
Strengths: Lighter than natural slate, lower cost, often impact- and fire-resistant, wide design options.
Weaknesses: Newer technology means long-term performance data is limited compared to slate or metal.

For homeowners who want the look of slate or cedar without the weight or constant maintenance, synthetic can be a smart middle ground.

Mistakes Homeowners Make When Choosing Shingles

Focusing only on upfront price. Asphalt shingles are cheaper today, but if you plan to stay in your house for decades, a metal or slate roof could save you money long-term.
Ignoring climate. A wood shake roof in a wet, humid climate will deteriorate quickly. A dark asphalt roof in a hot desert climate will raise cooling bills.
Overlooking installation. Even the best shingles fail if installed poorly. Choosing an experienced, certified installer is as important as the material itself.
Not checking building codes or HOA rules. Some areas restrict wood or certain colors/styles. Always check before investing.
Forgetting about weight. Slate and tile are heavy. Many homes need extra structural support before installation.

So, What Is the Best Type of Shingle?

There isn’t one universal answer. For most homeowners, architectural asphalt shingles hit the sweet spot of cost, durability, and availability. They look better than basic three-tab and hold up longer. For those who want a roof to last 50+ years, metal or synthetic shingles are strong contenders. Slate is the ultimate “forever roof,” but it’s not realistic for most budgets.

The best type of shingle is the one that matches your climate, budget, and long-term plans for the property. If you expect to move in 10 years, asphalt might be best. If you’re building a retirement home you plan to stay in, a higher-end material may pay off.

Call/Text Us for a FREE Estimate